Completed project · 2016–2019

UserGap

What is the influence of users on the performance gap in energy-efficient buildings?

The Eikenøtt neighbourhood in Gland, Vaud

About the project

Why do efficient buildings use more energy than planned?

UserGap is applied research on the factors behind the energy performance gap in Eikenøtt, a sustainable neighbourhood in Gland (Vaud), where Living Lab methods and tools were used to better understand the components of the gap and how to reduce it.

This interdisciplinary action research co-developed an energy action plan with key stakeholders through the Living Lab Integrative Process.

Our approach

Three levels of analysis, one shared picture

Macro

The neighbourhood

An econometric analysis of energy use across the neighbourhood.

Meso

The buildings

A technical analysis of how the buildings actually perform.

Micro

The households

A human factors analysis by social marketing specialists, to understand residents’ practices and barriers.

Methodology

The Living Lab Integrative Process

01

Problem space

Analysing energy consumption across the neighbourhood’s apartments, surveying residents and understanding the barriers to energy-efficient behaviour.

02

Solution space

Co-design workshops with residents and stakeholders to build an energy performance plan.

03

Deployment space

Measuring the effects on consumption and turning the findings into recommendations for future projects.

Lessons learned

What the research showed

Analysing social performance proved valuable alongside the technical and economic analyses, both for designing new neighbourhoods and for retrofit projects.

  • Energy and environmental factors do not directly drive residents’ satisfaction with living in the neighbourhood.
  • The “correct” use of blinds has a strong impact on heating consumption in low-energy buildings.
  • Automation can help users through default settings, but regulation and maintenance are often neglected.
  • Energy services and maintenance need leadership from an actor based in the neighbourhood.
  • There is a “social performance gap”, measured with an importance/performance matrix applied to energy.

Impact

Social, technical and economic impact

Greater engagement and empowerment Residents and stakeholders became actors of the neighbourhood’s energy performance.
Energy savings through co-design Solutions designed with users, so they fit how people really live in their homes.

Project partners

An interdisciplinary consortium

SFOE – Swiss Federal Office of Energy CRDE HES-SO Valais-Wallis HEIG-VD University of Neuchâtel TEP Energy Losinger Marazzi Bureau EHE

Buildings that work for their users

Working on a neighbourhood or retrofit project?

Let’s talk about how to involve residents from the start.

info@energylivinglab.com

This site uses cookies to offer you a
better browsing experience.